Multi-Family for Sale: 321 Bentley Avenue, Poultney, VT 05764

4 beds
2 full baths
2,851 sqft
$375,000
$375,000
321 Bentley Avenue, Poultney, VT 05764
4 beds
2 full baths
2,851 sqft
$375,000
Remove from
Favorites
Add to
Favorites
Add to
Trip Map
Hide Share or
Email
Price:
$375,000
$14,000 - 09/14/2026

Type Multi-Family
Style Colonial
Beds 4
Baths 2 full baths
Square Feet 2,851 sqft
Lot Size 0.45 acres
Year Built 1885
Taxes Paid $6,078

City Poultney
County Rutland

MLS 5061504
Status Active Under Contract
DOM 388 days
Welcome to this income-producing gem! Located in the heart of Poultney and within walking distance to schools, shopping, and public transportation, this charming 3-unit property presents a fantastic opportunity for both investors and owner-occupants alike. Each unit is bright, inviting, and full of character. The front unit features a classic covered porch, two bedrooms, and a full bath. The middle unit is light-filled with skylights, sliding glass doors that lead to a large private deck, and an easy, open layout perfect for comfortable living. The back unit, previously the owner’s quarters, offers a more modern layout and is currently vacant, making it ideal for immediate occupancy or premium rental potential. This spacious unit includes its own laundry area, minisplit system, separate mechanicals, and an impressive second-floor primary suite complete with cathedral ceilings, a walk-in closet, soaking tub, and private balcony. Additional highlights include an attached garage and a beautiful stone patio for outdoor enjoyment. For added convenience, the front two units share a washer and dryer located in the central hallway. Perfectly situated, this property is just 15 minutes from Vermont State University’s Castleton campus, less than an hour to multiple ski areas, 10 minutes to the New York border, and only minutes from both Lake St. Catherine and Lake Bomoseen. Whether you’re seeking a strong investment property or a home with additional rental income, this versatile multi-unit offers comfort, flexibility, and an unbeatable location.

Lot & Building Features

Utilities Cable
Construction Vinyl Siding, Wood Frame
Cooling Mini Split
Heating Radiant, Heat Pump, Multi Zone, Electric, Baseboard, Oil
Parking Description Parking Spaces 1 - 10, Heated Garage, Auto Open, Attached, Paved, Garage, Driveway
Sewer Public
Tax Year 2025
Taxes Paid $6,078
Water Public
Basement Description Unfinished
Foundation Block, Stone
Lot Description Curbing, Street Lights, Major Road Frontage, Near Country Club, Sidewalks, Near Public Transport, In Town, Walking Trails, Near Snowmobile Trails, Near Golf Course, Trail/Near Trail, Near Paths, Near Skiing, Near School(s), Neighborhood, Near Shopping, Landscaped, Level
Roof Slate, Shingle
Features Exterior Balcony, Patio, Covered Porch, Shed, Garden Space, Deck
Garage Yes

Community and Schools

Elementary School Poultney Elementary School
Junior High School Poultney High School
Senior High School Poultney High School

Unit Features

Unit 1 Baths 1
Unit 1 Bedrooms 2
Unit 1 Info Heat Included, Storage, Porch, Smoke Detector, Appliances Included, Electric Range, Refrigerator
Unit 1 Lease Term Month to Month
Unit 1 Rental Amount 1100.00
Unit 1 Rental Amt Freq Monthly
Unit 1 Status Leased
Unit 2 Baths 1
Unit 2 Bedrooms 1
Unit 2 Info Loft, Skylight, Primary BR w/ BA, Kitchen Island, Storage, Heat Included, Deck, Dishwasher, Smoke Detector, Appliances Included, Electric Range, Refrigerator
Unit 2 Lease Term Month to Month
Unit 2 Rental Amount 900.00
Unit 2 Rental Amt Freq Monthly
Unit 2 Status Leased
Unit 3 Baths 1
Unit 3 Bedrooms 1
Unit 3 Info Loft, Primary BR w/ BA, Cathedral Ceiling, Ceiling Fan, Gas Range, Heat Included, Laundry Hookup, Dishwasher, Appliances Included, Refrigerator
Unit 3 Status Vacant

Price History of 321 Bentley Avenue

Date Name Price Difference
09/14/2026 Price Adjustment $375,000 3.60%
05/05/2026 Price Adjustment $389,000 2.51%
09/16/2025 Listing Price $399,000 N/A
*Information provided by REWS for your reference only. The accuracy of this information cannot be verified and is not guaranteed.

Map of 321 Bentley Avenue, Poultney, VT

Location Map Street View
Listed by Lakes & Homes Real Estate, Heather Martelle 802-671-8042
Photo of Paula Munch
Direct: 603-548-0913
Office
655 Wallis Road.
Rye, NH 03870
603-964-7000
$
20%
1.6208106666667%
6.75%
$
$
$
Monthly Payment
Principal & Interest
Monthly Taxes
Monthly HOA
Monthly Home Ins.
Monthly PMI

321 Bentley Avenue (MLS #5061504) is a colonial multi-family listing located in Poultney, VT. This multi-family listing is 2,851 sqft and on a lot of 19,602 sqft (or 0.45 acres) with 4 bedrooms, 2 baths and is 141 years old. This property was listed on 09/16/2025 and has been priced for sale at $375,000.

Nearby zip codes are 05701, 05735, 05743, 05774 and 06764. This property neighbors other cities such as Castleton, Fair Haven and Wells.

PrimeMLS

Listing Last updated . Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available. Walk Score map and data provided by Walk Score. Google map provided by Google. Bing map provided by Microsoft Corporation.

All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Listing information courtesy of: Lakes & Homes Real Estate

Copyright 2026 PrimeMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate displayed on this display comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS. The information being provided is for consumers. personal, non- commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated 10/09/2026